Six Detroit Firefighters Injured at Taxpayer Fire from Wall Collapse

Detroit News

Six Detroit firefighters were injured during operations at a two alarm fire at a commercial taxpayer fire on the city’s east side. Initial reports indicate a roof collapse and subsequent compromise and further collapse occurred on the alpha side of operations with additional reports of an explosion preceding the collapse. Additional information provided by the Detroit Fire Department indicated the building structure had sustained some degree of damage from fire operations a few hours earlier and that during the suppression operations  at 07:00 hours, while companies were operating, a facade collapse of the perimeter brick wall occured.
The brick facade collapse trapped a number of firefighters under the debris pile requiring extrication and removal. Published report indicate that the following Detroit Firefighters were injured as a result of the collapsing facade wall;

• Lt. Gerald Rutkowski, 46; 23 years with department

• Shane Raxter, 32; 9 years with department.

• Brian Baulch, 31; 9 years with department.

• Jeron Whitehorn 30; 8 years with department.

• Eric Jurmo, 31; 11 years with department.

• Brendan Milewski, 31; 11 years with department

It appears the two story brick structure located at the corner block had commercial occupancies on the number one floor, with the second floor boarded up, evidenced by the coverings over the windows.
The facade collapse of the alpha side in the predominate location of perimeter windows is typically the least stable of areas in buildings of type III ordinary construction. Lacking any significant mass and increased wythe, non-bearing walls have less mass and require stability of the adjacent floor systems and load bearing lintels and beams to maintain structural stability and integrity. Gravity affects unstable brick veneer and in-fill walls greatly as does other imposed loads, hose and master streams impacts.  We’ll post more building construction insights and safety aides to increase your operational awareness on these type of building structures.
Here are the links to the lastest information forthcoming;
  • Detroit News, HERE
  • Firegeezer Coverage, HERE
  • Detroit Fox News, HERE
  • Latest news on FireFighter Nation, HERE
  •, Here
  • The Detroit Free Press, Here
  • Photo Gallery, Here
Here’s a link to a PPT program that’s available on the National Firefighter Near Miss Reporting System site on Operational Safety Considerations at Buildings of Ordinary and Heavy Timber Construction; Type III and IV Structures. An accompanying narrative is available on the same NMRS Resource page that I posted in 2009.
Some recent NIOSH Reports related to Commercial Building Occupancy Fires and their lessons;
  • Career Lieutenant Dies Following Floor Collapse into Basement Fire and a Career Fire Fighter Dies Attempting to Rescue the Career Lieutenant – New York,  HERE
  • Floor Collapse at Commercial Structure Fire Claims the Lives of One Career Lieutenant and One Career Fire Fighter – New York, Here
  • Hardware Store Explosion Claims the Lives of Three Career Fire Fighters-New York, Here
  • Volunteer Fire Chief Killed when Buried by Brick Parapet Wall Collapse – Texas, Here
  • Commercial Structure Fire Claims the Life of One Firefighter-California, Here
  • Partial roof collapse in commercial structure fire claims the lives of two career fire fighters – Tennessee, Here
Additionally here are some images pulled from various online sources depicting the building, it’s construction, layout and configuration.

Detroit New Photo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Chris Naum

  • administration-leadership (28)
  • Attitude (21)
  • building construction (96)
  • (104)
  • Chief Fire Officer (10)
  • christopher naum (167)
  • Collapse (19)
  • command (8)
  • command-leadership (75)
  • (75)
  • company officer (135)
  • Credentialing (7)
  • Crew Integrity (20)
  • Crew Management (26)
  • Culture (15)
  • Doug Cline (39)
  • Education (23)
  • FDNY (8)
  • Fire Dynamics (30)
  • Fire Engineering (1)
  • Fire Fighter Safety (61)
  • Fire Fighting (48)
  • Fire Suppression (72)
  • fire-prevention-education (4)
  • fire-rescue-topics (5)
  • firefighter-safety-health (52)
  • firefighting-operations (130)
  • fires (18)
  • Fitness (3)
  • funding-staffing (1)
  • Future (17)
  • hazmat (1)
  • Health and Safety (6)
  • High-rise (5)
  • Higher Education (3)
  • History Repeating Event (15)
  • IAFF (2)
  • in-the-line-of-duty (9)
  • KSA (15)
  • Leaderhip (52)
  • leadership (31)
  • line-of-duty (11)
  • LODD (35)
  • major-incidents (18)
  • mass-casualty-incident (4)
  • Mentor (17)
  • Near-Miss Reporting (6)
  • NIOSH Reports (21)
  • NIST (2)
  • Occupancies (24)
  • Officer (47)
  • operations (25)
  • patient-management (1)
  • planning (7)
  • Professional Development (33)
  • promotion (7)
  • Reports (6)
  • rescues (1)
  • Research (11)
  • Residential (3)
  • Risk Assessment (33)
  • Risk Management (28)
  • Scenarios (10)
  • Situational Awareness (58)
  • skills (26)
  • special-operations (1)
  • Strategy and Tactics (72)
  • Structural Collapse (8)
  • Succession Planning (19)
  • Taking it to the Streets (28)
  • technology-communications (1)
  • Ten Minutes in the Street Scenarios (7)
  • (45)
  • Topical Fire Report Series (1)
  • Tradition (18)
  • training (44)
  • training-development (57)
  • training-fire-rescue-topics (8)
  • Uncategorized (40)
  • USFA (5)
  • vehicle-operations-apparatus (1)
  • videos (2)
  • Comments
    Sizeup – Backstep Firefighter
    Situational Awareness and The Three Sixty
    [...] the first arriving officer completing a 360 check of the building upon arrival. In his article “Situational Awareness and the Three Sixty”, Christopher Naum makes the following statement, “The effective assessment of the incident [...]
    2010-11-30 08:03:47
    Vacant Residential Building Fires Report | Command Safety
    From Waldbaum’s to Hackensack- Worcester to Charleston; Legacies for Operational Safety
    [...]  From Waldbaum’s to Hackensack- Worcester to Charleston; Legacies for Operational Safety [...]
    2010-11-19 21:42:26
    Taking it to the Streets; “Redefining the Fire Ground” Rescheduled | The Company Officer
    Douglas Cline
    [...] Douglas Cline [...]
    2010-11-03 21:10:21
    Taking it to the Streets; “Redefining the Fire Ground” Rescheduled | Command Safety
    Douglas Cline
    [...] assumptions and deployments continue to be willfully miscued.  Joining Chris will be Chief Douglas Cline, from the City of High Point FD, North Carolina, a highly regarded national instructor, author, [...]
    2010-11-03 20:51:28
    John Shafer
    The Predictability of Occupancy Performance and Tactical Patience
    Amen Brother! Good Article :)
    2010-10-22 22:00:53
    It's OK.
    It's OK.
    Welcome to the Club
    Welcome to the Club
    Author Unknown
    The Part We Forget
    The Part We Forget
    The Real Problem With Ray Rice
    The Real Problem With Ray Rice

    Taking it to the Streets on BlogTalk Radio

    banner ad The Newest radio show on FireFighter at Blogtalk Radio… Taking it to the Streets with Christopher Naum. On the Air Monthly on Firefighter A Series and Firefighter Production. Advancing Firefighter Safety and Operational Integrity for the Fire Service through provocative insights and dynamic discussions dedicated to the Art and Science of Firefighting and the Traditions of the Fire Service.

    banner ad

    Fire & Training with Chief Doug Cline

    banner ad

    FirefighterNetCast on Blog Talk Radio

    Listen to internet radio with FirefighterNetCast on Blog Talk Radio

    Connect with

    banner ad

    QR Code for

    Quick Response Code qrcode

    FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

    Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter